Skip to main content

Respect and Loathing in American Democracy

Polarization, Moralization, and the Undermining of Equality

A deep examination of why respect is in short supply in politics today and why it matters.

Respect is in trouble in the United States. Many Americans believe respecting others is a necessary virtue, yet many struggle to respect opposing partisans. Surprisingly, it is liberal citizens, who hold respect as central to their view of democratic equality, who often have difficulty granting respect to others. Drawing on evidence from national surveys, focus groups, survey experiments, and the views of political theorists, Jeff Spinner-Halev and Elizabeth Theiss-Morse explain why this is and why respect is vital to—and yet so lacking in—contemporary US politics.

Respect and Loathing in American Democracy argues that liberals and conservatives are less divided than many believe, but alienate one another because they moralize different issues. Liberals moralize social justice, conservatives champion national solidarity, and this worldview divide keeps them at odds.

Respect is both far-reaching and vital, yet it is much harder to grant than many recognize, partly because of the unseen tension between respect, social justice, and national solidarity. Respect and Loathing in American Democracy proposes a path forward that, while challenging, is far from impossible for citizens to traverse.


280 pages | 33 line drawings, 23 tables | 6 x 9 | © 2024

Chicago Studies in American Politics

Political Science: Political Behavior and Public Opinion

Reviews

"This work nicely blends political theory and the empirical study of behavior to construct an important examination of democracy in the US today."

Choice

Respect and Loathing in American Democracy breaks much new ground. It brings normative insight to bear on fresh data to illuminate a problem at the core of democracy in our time: why people have such a hard time respecting those on the other side of our polarized partisan divide. An important book.”

Stephen Macedo | Princeton University

“Spinner-Halev and Theiss-Morse take their own road to assessing what ails American politics. Whereas there are numerous books and articles on racism/identity, nationalism, and white working-class politics, Respect and Loathing in American Democracy tells a novel story that is thoughtful, rich in evidence, and engaging."

Matthew Wright | University of British Columbia

Table of Contents

Preface

Part I. Respect: The Challenge of Democracy and Equality
1. Democratic Equality and the Importance of Respect
2. Is It Possible to Respect Opposing Partisans?
3. The Failed Aspirations of Civic Respect

Part II. Loathing: Why Is Respect So Hard to Grant?
4. The Social Justice Worldview and Moralization
5. The National Solidarity Worldview and Moralization
6. Collective Responsibility and Judging Others

Part III. Democracy: The Importance of Saving Respect
7. Respect versus Justice?
8. Struggling toward Respect

Acknowledgments
Appendix A. Focus Groups
Appendix B. Surveys
Appendix C. Survey Questions and Scales
Appendix D. Regression Results
Notes
References
Index

Be the first to know

Get the latest updates on new releases, special offers, and media highlights when you subscribe to our email lists!

Sign up here for updates about the Press